Seven semesters of residency not necessary
by Avi Snyder
Columnist
Op-Ed | 10/27/09
Posted online at 9:36 PM EST on 10/26/09
/ Last updated at 2:30 PM EST on 10/26/09
Yes, the University is incredibly generous with financial aid (I myself am here on a large scholarship), but for many families, especially in times of economic hardship, college remains tremendously expensive even with aid. Just as students often work harder in high school in order to earn scholarships for college, some Brandeis students would work harder by taking more courses a semester to graduate early and save a great deal of money.
The second reason the University should allow its students to graduate in fewer than seven semesters is that despite the value Brandeis puts on a broad liberal arts education, some people simply don't need time to explore different fields of study. For many students, myself included, the fact that I do not have to declare a major until halfway through my college career in incredibly liberating. It allows students like me to explore new fields of study and discover what we love.
But for many other students, this period of discovery is a waste of time. There are plenty of people who come to Brandeis knowing that they want to be doctors, and from the moment they arrive on campus they pursue the course of study that will get them to that goal. For such people, it may seem ridiculous that they be required to stay on campus for seven semesters so they can have time to discover what they love to study. They already know. Furthermore, the University class requirements for graduating already ensure that students graduating from the University have a basic knowledge of a broad range of fields of study. Students who graduate early ought to be expected to fulfill these requirements just like any other student at the University.
The last and most important reason Brandeis should allow its students to graduate in fewer than seven semesters is that the University ought to trust us to make our own decisions about our academic life. We are adults, and we ought to be trusted to decide how we chart our courses of study in college. The University can and ought to promote a broad liberal arts education for its students, but it cannot force its students to get such an education.
Some may say that students who do not have an interest in getting a good liberal arts education should simply not come to our University. After all, there are other schools that allow their students the opportunity to graduate in three years or less. I believe that Brandeis shouldn't exclude such students from experiencing what Brandeis has to offer. There is a plethora of reasons why someone may want to come to Brandeis, including our family-like community, the phenomenal extracurricular opportunities and the wonderful faculty members that actually care about undergraduates. Perhaps there are many students out there who value these aspects of our University but for whatever reason want to get out of here a bit early. Why should we exclude bright minds who want to come here simply because we judge them to not share all of our values?
The second reason the University should allow its students to graduate in fewer than seven semesters is that despite the value Brandeis puts on a broad liberal arts education, some people simply don't need time to explore different fields of study. For many students, myself included, the fact that I do not have to declare a major until halfway through my college career in incredibly liberating. It allows students like me to explore new fields of study and discover what we love.
But for many other students, this period of discovery is a waste of time. There are plenty of people who come to Brandeis knowing that they want to be doctors, and from the moment they arrive on campus they pursue the course of study that will get them to that goal. For such people, it may seem ridiculous that they be required to stay on campus for seven semesters so they can have time to discover what they love to study. They already know. Furthermore, the University class requirements for graduating already ensure that students graduating from the University have a basic knowledge of a broad range of fields of study. Students who graduate early ought to be expected to fulfill these requirements just like any other student at the University.
The last and most important reason Brandeis should allow its students to graduate in fewer than seven semesters is that the University ought to trust us to make our own decisions about our academic life. We are adults, and we ought to be trusted to decide how we chart our courses of study in college. The University can and ought to promote a broad liberal arts education for its students, but it cannot force its students to get such an education.
Some may say that students who do not have an interest in getting a good liberal arts education should simply not come to our University. After all, there are other schools that allow their students the opportunity to graduate in three years or less. I believe that Brandeis shouldn't exclude such students from experiencing what Brandeis has to offer. There is a plethora of reasons why someone may want to come to Brandeis, including our family-like community, the phenomenal extracurricular opportunities and the wonderful faculty members that actually care about undergraduates. Perhaps there are many students out there who value these aspects of our University but for whatever reason want to get out of here a bit early. Why should we exclude bright minds who want to come here simply because we judge them to not share all of our values?






Viewing Comments 1 - 2 of 3
Dev Singer '11
posted 10/27/09 @ 3:54 AM EST
I would like to add a point to this editorial, if I may:
There are ALREADY students, such as myself, who don't spend seven semesters on campus. As long as students are allowed to study abroad for a year, there will be students who are only physically at Brandeis for six semesters. (Continued…)
Eli Harrington
posted 10/27/09 @ 12:26 PM EST
Good topic for a column, but I disagree with the overall opinion and the reasons you list and I'll tell you why:
1--if someone is bright enough to get into Brandeis and possibly finish in 3 years, wouldn't we expect them to have enough financial aid for that final year? Furthermore, who can afford to go to Brandeis for 6 semesters, but not 7? This is why we have such generous financial aid programs (from which I also benefited), to make sure these bright students are able to stay here as long as they need to complete their degree. (Continued…)
Post a Comment